An Open Letter to the Religious

I’d like to take a moment to write an article speaking directly to those of you that are religious. This is a completely honest, me to you letter, asking you to indulge in taking a step back and evaluating your religion. I promise this will not take long, and I’m not asking you to “become an atheist for a day” or anything like that. We are just considering propositions.

Not all of you are willing to do that, and I get it. If you aren’t open to examining your religion from the outside, this letter will likely not resonate with you at all. But for many of you, your intellectual curiosity may be willing to hear me out. If this is you, then I appreciate it greatly.

Let’s consider the landscape of world religions. All religions. Right now in the world, there are approximately 10,000 religions. Practicing these religions are many intelligent, thoughtful, logical people. I have personally met many of them. If we were to speak to a Muslim or Sikh or Hindu medical doctor, it is safe to assume that this person is no dolt. Medical school, in any country, is a lengthy and difficult process involving memorizing thousands of body parts and chemicals and functions, how they all interact with each other, constant logical evaluation of symptoms, and the ability to make determinations and recommend treatment for thousands of ailments. Yet that doctor still believes in a particular religion that you believe is false.

Have you ever considered, and I mean REALLY considered, why these really intelligent and competent people still believe in their religions? Does it make you wonder why someone that saves lives by being logical and correct also believes in something you believe is completely wrong? Can you actually put yourself in their place and see why they believe, and could you explain where they are wrong?

Let’s consider what many would call outlandish or cartoonish claims of other religions. It is easy from the outside to identify fanciful elements of someone else’s religion, such as the Muslim belief that Muhammed rode a winged horse to heaven. Yet billions of Christians believe Jesus rose body and soul to heaven. As Sam Harris has cleverly noted, why is the addition of a winged horse the only thing that makes the claim absurd? Indeed, every religion has absurd claims. And if true, they would be truly outstanding! If Jesus really flew, or Muhammed really rode a winged horse, it would be a world-altering experience for any witnesses, and a legitimate miracle.

But which one is actually true, if either? What criteria can we develop to determine if these claims are true or false, other than lots of people believing in the one they were taught? What can we study to determine if they are true or false? And since I’m asking you to be completely honest here, if you are able to determine a method to identify a false religious claim, will your religious claim be able to stand up to the scrutiny as well?

Let’s consider the idea of your belief because of how your religion stands above the others. For example, I have heard many people say that only their religion has a god that does such-and-such. The such-and-such could be dying for our sins, or established a moral law, has a personal relationship with you, or grew into a major world religion from humble beginnings. Have you discussed the superiority of your religious belief with anyone? I not only imagine this would be extremely satisfying to believe in a correct and superior belief, I actually used to believe I believed in the superior belief. You really feel comfortable that this is the way you believe it to be, possibly something you couldn’t fathom being any other way.

Now again, let’s take a step back and survey the religious landscape. While every religion is unique in some way or another (otherwise they wouldn’t be different religions), the world religions are on a spectrum. To a non-believer like me, I don’t see anything in any one religion that really stands out as being worthy of consideration. If you tell me your savior died for your sins, I’ll find a half-dozen other religions that claim the same. If you tell me only your religion had a prophet that wrote down the words of god, or that only your religion still follows that original lineage, I’ll find a half-dozen other religions that claim the same thing. If you claim only your religion grew exponentially, I’ll find a half-dozen other religions that also grew remarkably quick or quicker. If you claim it isn’t a religion but a relationship….. that’s literally what every adherent to every religion thinks. The nature of the relationship is the only difference. And if you think your religion is the most moral, I can easily find religions that have moral codes that could be objectively considered more moral.

So if you believe your religion is superior or the only one “true” religion, can you honestly find something in your religion that truly makes it so? I know you can list a whole lot of things about your religion that you think are great, but why do you think they are the best? How do you know they aren’t just “pretty good?” And again, if you were to be completely honest, is there anything about your religion you think could be way better? If you were literally god for a day, with all the power in the universe to set up everything, would you have done anything different? Would childhood leukemia and rape be less frequent, or even non-existent, in your universe? Would clarifying your desires so people don’t kill each other in your name be something you would try?

Let’s consider our fallible senses, and our fallible memories as well. We know the game of telephone results in wrong and often hilarious misinterpretations. We know that a day riding the rollercoasters causes all sorts of odd sensations, sometimes hours later. We know we can be tricked by the illusionists who really are just pulling a trick. We know people can hallucinate for a lot of reasons that don’t involve drugs, including lack of sleep or food, stress, traumatic experiences, and sensory deprivation. We know that people’s memory of an event can be altered through suggestion. We know that people’s memory of an event can just be wrong! We know that damage or pressure to specific parts of the brain can result in quite interesting effects, like the inability to recognize faces despite being able to read and pass any eye test. Damage another part of the brain and you might be able to read or write but become unable to speak. Some people can barely speak, but when singing have a full, rich voice. And certain brain damage or disease results in a change or loss of someone’s entire personality.

Do you think it possible that people of other religions have convinced themselves, based on poorly interpreting their fallible senses, that their religion is real? If so, how are you able to determine that you aren’t misinterpreting your own senses? What is the difference between them praying earnestly and feeling clarity, and you praying earnestly and feeling clarity?

If you have read this far, and not skipped to the end, I think you will at least UNDERSTAND why I am an atheist. But I am interested in hearing what you think. Where am I wrong? Is there really something about your religion that stands out from the “false” religions? Is there any feature of your religion that truly makes it stand above the fray, and is worth considering?

As always, my comment section is open for discussion. And as always, if you don’t address the questions I have posed, and just try to preach and post links to youtube videos, I will delete your comments. Thanks in advance!

The Spartan Atheist

8 thoughts on “An Open Letter to the Religious

  1. Well written. I seriously doubt any theist would want to answer or would be able to answer. I guess they may claim that they believe certain prophesies from their holly books are true, miracles happen, prayers are answered and that makes their god a real god. Apart from that sort of fluff that most religions claim maybe some will claim their god is a real alien that travels in a flying saucer and had visited them regularly, now wouldn’t that be far more creditable tale 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  2. James Bargeron June 12, 2021 — 2:20 pm

    I was raised going to church and “Sunday school” and it never did click with me that it was real, more like superman in the comic books. Church was a fun place to meet friends but I will not prostitute myself into pretending to believe the fairy tales any more. There is a fine line between superstition and religion that most people do not acknowledge.
    To elaborate on your theme of many religions, The christian religion has many denominations within itself- there is catholicism and dozens of different protestant churches. There are different branches within denominations as well. One god, many interpretations.
    I do not see joy in the misfortune of others, but I saw some irony last year when an area church burned because it was struck by lightning.
    Thank you for your insights!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you, James. Yeah, the predictions of religious leaders, such as safety or health, seem to not bear out ever.


  3. I can’t speak for “other” religions, but I do know that none of the points you mentioned make an iota of difference to a True Christian™ because, for them, it’s all in the feeelings. They may be led into the religion via “the book” and/or other external sources, but once they’re there, it’s all based on emotion.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thats exactly what I’m asking them. How are their feelings any more a measure of reality than someone else with different feelings?


      1. From my experiences, they don’t understand your question because their god/religion/belief is “different” from all the others so your questions are moot.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. I believe you are saying what I have always thought. If explaining to theists of a strong indoctrinated belief in their god that many other religions are similar but with a different god and worshippers who are as dedicated as they are, these theists will not absorb the question as it is intended and interpret it as an affront or insult to their knowledge and wise decisions regarding their religion of choice, plus they have a mind washed contempt and deep repugnance to the other religions. They may see the question a bit like an uneducated no-hoper asking a mathematical fanatic if they know how to add numbers to get a total. Indoctrination is very dangerous mind control.

        Liked by 2 people

  4. These are some of the questions that many religious people are pressured not to think about. The indoctrinated pre-programmed response to perfectly reasonable questions like this can range from “LaLaLa I can’t hear you” to “You have obviously been deceived by SATAN!!!” For people who are raised in a religion, but are willing to think seriously about questions like this, well, there are more and more of us de-converts every day.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close